Horse Thief Hollow Menu
Lunch & Dinner - Appetizers
Buffalo Wings
Juicy jumbo chicken wings with celery & carrots, ranch or blue cheese, & your choice of Buffalo, O’Learys Hot, Korean BBQ or Mango Habañero sauce.*
$
Spent Grain Pretzels
Tender pretzel nuggets made from spent brewers’ grain & served with roasted poblano queso.
US$9.00
Buffalo Shrimp
Lightly breaded extra large Texas brown shrimp served with carrots and celery, blue cheese or ranch dressing & your choice of Buffalo, O’Leary’s Hot, Korean BBQ or Mango Habanero.*
US$15.00
Pulled Pork Nachos
House smoked, hand pulled pork on tortilla chips with roasted poblano queso, salsa fresca, jalapeño, avocado crema, cotija cheese, & cilantro.
US$15.00
Reuben Egg Rolls
Hand made with Whittingham’s corned beef, kraut, Swiss cheese & 1000 Island
US$12.00
Lunch & Dinner - Soups & Salads
Coastal Shrimp Salad
Old Bay-dusted extra large Texas Brown shrimp, house bacon, grilled corn, sweet peppers, avocado, cornbread crunch, cotija cheese, mixed greens, cilantro lime ranch.
US$16.00
Blackened Chicken Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, radicchio, sourdough croutons, blackened chicken breast, lava egg, parmesan, black pepper, Old Bay Caesar dressing.*
US$15.00
Old Man Tom’s Gumbo
Extra large Texas Brown shrimp, blue crab, clams, house made andouille.*
$
Steakhouse Wedge Salad
Iceberg wedge, house-smoked bacon, cherry tomato, crumbled blue cheese, pink peppercorn ranch.
US$14.00
‘Beyond’ Kitchen Sink Chili
Ground plant-based Beyond Beef, fire roasted tomatoes, Kitchen Sink Pale Ale, 3 types of beans & 5 varieties of peppers.
$
Lunch & Dinner - Burgers
Double Stack Smash
Two 1⁄4-lb patties of our fresh ground beef from the HTH Angus herd. Served on buttered brioche with American & cheddar cheeses, Merzy's squickles, roasted tomato aioli, & caramelized onion.
$
Backyard Grilled Angus
1⁄2 lb. fresh ground beef from the HTH herd. Served on a toasted Challah bun with iceberg, tomato, red onion, & choice of American, cheddar, white cheddar, pepper jack, smoked Gouda, or blue cheese.*
$
Southwest Turkey Burger
1⁄2 lb. ground turkey, pepper jack cheese, avocado, fried jalapeño, lettuce, tomato, onion, chipotle ranch.*
$
Hoppin’ John Veggie Burger
Hoppin’ John patty made with Carolina Gold rice & black eyed peas, roasted poblano, cashews, white cheddar, pickled red onion, & chive crème fraîche.
$
Chicken Pesto Sammy
$
Miatake Gruyere Burger
$
Lunch & Dinner - A La Carte
Side Corn Bread
US$2.00
Side French Fries
US$5.00
Side Salad
US$5.00
Side Sweet Potato Fries
US$5.00
Appetizers
Buffalo Wings
Juicy jumbo chicken wings with celery & carrots, ranch or blue cheese, & your choice of Buffalo, O’Learys Hot, Korean BBQ or Mango Habañero sauce.*
$
Spent Grain Pretzels
Tender pretzel nuggets made from spent brewers’ grain & served with roasted poblano queso.
US$9.00
Buffalo Shrimp
Lightly breaded extra large Texas brown shrimp served with carrots and celery, blue cheese or ranch dressing & your choice of Buffalo, O’Leary’s Hot, Korean BBQ or Mango Habanero.*
US$15.00
Pulled Pork Nachos
House smoked, hand pulled pork on tortilla chips with roasted poblano queso, salsa fresca, jalapeño, avocado crema, cotija cheese, & cilantro.
US$15.00
Reuben Egg Rolls
Hand made with Whittingham’s corned beef, kraut, Swiss cheese & 1000 Island
US$12.00
Beignets
House-made beignets, dusted in powdered sugar & cinnamon. Drizzled with cinnamon glaze.
US$9.00
Pumpkin Cheesecake Empanadas
A collaboration with our friends at Let’s Get Poppin, our take on the Chicago Mix is a blend of pimento cheese popcorn & pecan pie popcorn.
US$9.00
Scotch Egg
US$15.00
Soups & Salads
Coastal Shrimp Salad
Old Bay-dusted extra large Texas Brown shrimp, house bacon, grilled corn, sweet peppers, avocado, cornbread crunch, cotija cheese, mixed greens, cilantro lime ranch.
US$16.00
Blackened Chicken Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, radicchio, sourdough croutons, blackened chicken breast, lava egg, parmesan, black pepper, Old Bay Caesar dressing.*
US$15.00
Old Man Tom’s Gumbo
Extra large Texas Brown shrimp, blue crab, clams, house made andouille.*
$
Steakhouse Wedge Salad
Iceberg wedge, house-smoked bacon, cherry tomato, crumbled blue cheese, pink peppercorn ranch.
US$14.00
‘Beyond’ Kitchen Sink Chili
Ground plant-based Beyond Beef, fire roasted tomatoes, Kitchen Sink Pale Ale, 3 types of beans & 5 varieties of peppers.
$
Burgers
Double Stack Smash
Two 1⁄4-lb patties of our fresh ground beef from the HTH Angus herd. Served on buttered brioche with American & cheddar cheeses, Merzy's squickles, roasted tomato aioli, & caramelized onion.
$
Backyard Grilled Angus
1⁄2 lb. fresh ground beef from the HTH herd. Served on a toasted Challah bun with iceberg, tomato, red onion, & choice of American, cheddar, white cheddar, pepper jack, smoked Gouda, or blue cheese.*
$
Southwest Turkey Burger
1⁄2 lb. ground turkey, pepper jack cheese, avocado, fried jalapeño, lettuce, tomato, onion, chipotle ranch.*
$
Hoppin’ John Veggie Burger
Hoppin’ John patty made with Carolina Gold rice & black eyed peas, roasted poblano, cashews, white cheddar, pickled red onion, & chive crème fraîche.
$
Chicken Pesto Sammy
$
Miatake Gruyere Burger
$
A La Carte
Side Corn Bread
US$2.00
Side French Fries
US$5.00
Side Salad
US$5.00
Side Sweet Potato Fries
US$5.00
Side Bacon
US$5.00
Sausage Link
US$5.00
House Potatoes
US$5.00
Side Egg
US$2.00
Dinner Entrees - Dinner Entrees
Paella Inspired Risotto
Gulf shrimp, grilled chicken, spanish chorizo, garlic, roasted bell pepper, fresh herbs, Carolina Gold rice.
US$24.00
Flat Iron Steak
10 oz. grilled flat iron steak, chimichurri compound butter. Choice of two sides.
$
Preserved Lemon Salmon
Grilled Faroe Islands salmon, preserved lemon gremolata. Choice of two sides.
$
Korean Fire Chicken
A Kimski & HTH collaboration. Spicy marinated grilled chicken leg & thigh, Korean rice cakes, mozzarella, green onion, toasted sesame, & cucumber.
US$24.00
Lake Perch
US$25.00
Dinner Entrees
Paella Inspired Risotto
Gulf shrimp, grilled chicken, spanish chorizo, garlic, roasted bell pepper, fresh herbs, Carolina Gold rice.
US$24.00
Flat Iron Steak
10 oz. grilled flat iron steak, chimichurri compound butter. Choice of two sides.
$
Preserved Lemon Salmon
Grilled Faroe Islands salmon, preserved lemon gremolata. Choice of two sides.
$
Korean Fire Chicken
A Kimski & HTH collaboration. Spicy marinated grilled chicken leg & thigh, Korean rice cakes, mozzarella, green onion, toasted sesame, & cucumber.
US$24.00
Lake Perch
US$25.00
Lunch Sandwiches - Sandwiches
Mexican Street Corn Wrap
$
Cubano
$
Hen House BLT
$
Roasted Veggie Wrap
$
Sandwiches
Mexican Street Corn Wrap
$
Cubano
$
Hen House BLT
$
Roasted Veggie Wrap
$
Brunch - Appetizers
Beignets
House-made beignets, dusted in powdered sugar & cinnamon. Drizzled with cinnamon glaze.
US$9.00
Spent Grain Pretzels
Tender pretzel nuggets made from spent brewers’ grain & served with roasted poblano queso.
US$9.00
Buffalo Wings
Juicy jumbo chicken wings with celery & carrots, ranch or blue cheese, & your choice of Buffalo, O’Learys Hot, Korean BBQ or Mango Habañero sauce.*
$
Pumpkin Cheesecake Empanadas
A collaboration with our friends at Let’s Get Poppin, our take on the Chicago Mix is a blend of pimento cheese popcorn & pecan pie popcorn.
US$9.00
Scotch Egg
US$15.00
Brunch - Entrees
Breakfast Burrito
Fried egg, cheddar, house bacon & sausage link, smashing fingerling house potatoes.*
US$14.00
Steak & Eggs
5 oz. filet mignon, 2 eggs your way, chimichurri butter, smashed fingerling house potatoes.*
US$24.00
Avocado Toast
Brioche, blueberry sauce, lemon whipped cream.
US$11.00
Saddle Bags
2 eggs your way, smashed fingerling house potatoes, house smoked bacon & hot link, sourdough toast with house apple butter & jams.*
US$15.00
Huevos Rancheros
House-made chorizo, Chihuaha cheese, guajillo salsa, refried black beans, avocado crema & 2 eggs your way, all over tortilla chips. Omit chorizo for vegetarian option.*
US$14.00
Griddle Cakes
English muffin, country ham, 2 poached eggs, hollandaise, smashed fingerling house potatoes.*
US$13.00
Brunch - Sandwiches & Burgers
BLT
House smoked bacon, heirloom tomato, bacon aioli, & Little Gem lettuce on toasted sourdough.
$
Southwest Turkey Burger
1⁄2 lb. ground turkey, pepper jack cheese, avocado, fried jalapeño, lettuce, tomato, onion, chipotle ranch.*
$
Backyard Grilled Angus
1⁄2 lb. fresh ground beef from the HTH herd. Served on a toasted Challah bun with iceberg, tomato, red onion, & choice of American, cheddar, white cheddar, pepper jack, smoked Gouda, or blue cheese.*
US$16.00
Brunch - Soups & Salads
Old Man Tom’s Gumbo
Extra large Texas Brown shrimp, blue crab, clams, house made andouille.*
$
‘Beyond’ Kitchen Sink Chili
Ground plant-based Beyond Beef, fire roasted tomatoes, Kitchen Sink Pale Ale, 3 types of beans & 5 varieties of peppers.
$
Coastal Shrimp Salad
Old Bay-dusted extra large Texas Brown shrimp, house bacon, grilled corn, sweet peppers, avocado, cornbread crunch, cotija cheese, mixed greens, cilantro lime ranch.
US$16.00
Blackened Chicken Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, radicchio, sourdough croutons, blackened chicken breast, lava egg, parmesan, black pepper, Old Bay Caesar dressing.*
US$15.00
Brunch - A La Carte
Side French Fries
US$5.00
Side Sweet Potato Fries
US$5.00
Side Corn Bread
US$2.00
Side Salad
US$5.00
Side Bacon
US$5.00
Sausage Link
US$5.00
House Potatoes
US$5.00
Side Egg
US$2.00
Entrees
Breakfast Burrito
Fried egg, cheddar, house bacon & sausage link, smashing fingerling house potatoes.*
US$14.00
Steak & Eggs
5 oz. filet mignon, 2 eggs your way, chimichurri butter, smashed fingerling house potatoes.*
US$24.00
Avocado Toast
Brioche, blueberry sauce, lemon whipped cream.
US$11.00
Saddle Bags
2 eggs your way, smashed fingerling house potatoes, house smoked bacon & hot link, sourdough toast with house apple butter & jams.*
US$15.00
Huevos Rancheros
House-made chorizo, Chihuaha cheese, guajillo salsa, refried black beans, avocado crema & 2 eggs your way, all over tortilla chips. Omit chorizo for vegetarian option.*
US$14.00
Griddle Cakes
English muffin, country ham, 2 poached eggs, hollandaise, smashed fingerling house potatoes.*
US$13.00
Sandwiches & Burgers
BLT
House smoked bacon, heirloom tomato, bacon aioli, & Little Gem lettuce on toasted sourdough.
$
Southwest Turkey Burger
1⁄2 lb. ground turkey, pepper jack cheese, avocado, fried jalapeño, lettuce, tomato, onion, chipotle ranch.*
$
Backyard Grilled Angus
1⁄2 lb. fresh ground beef from the HTH herd. Served on a toasted Challah bun with iceberg, tomato, red onion, & choice of American, cheddar, white cheddar, pepper jack, smoked Gouda, or blue cheese.*
US$16.00
Kids Menu - Kids Menu
Kids' Fried Chicken Fingers
With choice of dipping sauce
$
Kids' Grilled Chicken Fingers
With choice of dipping sauce
$
Kids' Angus Beef Sliders
Two Angus beef sliders with choice of cheese
$
Kids' Grilled Cheese
Choice of cheese
$
Kids' Macaroni & Cheese
$
Kids' Pulled Pork Sliders
Two pulled pork sliders with sweet BBQ sauce
$
Kids' Mini Flat Bread Pizza
$
Kids Menu
Kids' Fried Chicken Fingers
With choice of dipping sauce
$
Kids' Grilled Chicken Fingers
With choice of dipping sauce
$
Kids' Angus Beef Sliders
Two Angus beef sliders with choice of cheese
$
Kids' Grilled Cheese
Choice of cheese
$
Kids' Macaroni & Cheese
$
Kids' Pulled Pork Sliders
Two pulled pork sliders with sweet BBQ sauce
$
Kids' Mini Flat Bread Pizza
$
Dessert - Dessert
Triple Chocolate Flourless Cake
Semisweet, milk, & bittersweet chocolate.
US$7.00
Beignets
House-made beignets, dusted in powdered sugar & cinnamon. Drizzled with cinnamon glaze.
US$9.00
Lemon Cake
Dense, smooth key lime custard, Graham cracker crust, strawberry coulis, whipped cream.
US$9.00
Deep Fried Oreo Sundae
Deep fried Oreo cookies, vanilla gelato, chocolate sauce, whipped cream, shaved chocolate sprinkles, Luxardo cherry.
US$9.00
Biscoff Cheesecake
US$8.00
Root Beer Float
US$6.00
Key Lime Pie
US$7.00
Blueberry Pie
US$8.00
Pumpkin Tiramisu
US$9.00
Dessert
Triple Chocolate Flourless Cake
Semisweet, milk, & bittersweet chocolate.
US$7.00
Beignets
House-made beignets, dusted in powdered sugar & cinnamon. Drizzled with cinnamon glaze.
US$9.00
Lemon Cake
Dense, smooth key lime custard, Graham cracker crust, strawberry coulis, whipped cream.
US$9.00
Deep Fried Oreo Sundae
Deep fried Oreo cookies, vanilla gelato, chocolate sauce, whipped cream, shaved chocolate sprinkles, Luxardo cherry.
US$9.00
Biscoff Cheesecake
US$8.00
Root Beer Float
US$6.00
Key Lime Pie
US$7.00
Blueberry Pie
US$8.00
Pumpkin Tiramisu
US$9.00
Beer To Go - 4 packs
4-Pack Little Wing
Our multi-award winning flagship lager. Crisp, clean, refreshing, Little Wing combines American malt with German Tettnang hops to delight your tastebuds. 5.2% ABV
US$12.00
4-Pack Spoonful
Double Dry Hopped Hazy IPA with Mosaic and Citra Hops 6.5% ABV
US$16.00
4-Pack Annexation
West Coast IPA featuring citrus and pine notes with a firm bitterness and semi-dry finish. 7.2% ABV
US$14.00
4-Pack Delta Hurricane
Imperial Milk Stout with Chicory and Coffee. Inspired by the New Orleans traditional coffee and chicory blend, Delta Hurricane is our own take on the coffee milk stout. The base stout recipe is built on flavors of roasted barley, coffee, and dark chocolate balanced by a light punch of American hops on top of a full bodied beer, thanks in part to the addition of lactose. This batch uses the Night Moves Blend from our friends at Passion House Coffee. To round everything out in the New Orleans tradition, we blended in pure chicory sourced from a New Orleans roaster for a subtle woody and nutty character. The resulting beer is part Chicago, part New Orleans, and all Horse Thief Hollow. 8.0% ABV
US$16.00
4-Pack Kitchen Sink
Classic American Pale Ale with a caramel malt backbone featuring a load of hops with Cascade at the forefront. 5.3% ABV
US$12.00
4 packs
4-Pack Little Wing
Our multi-award winning flagship lager. Crisp, clean, refreshing, Little Wing combines American malt with German Tettnang hops to delight your tastebuds. 5.2% ABV
US$12.00
4-Pack Spoonful
Double Dry Hopped Hazy IPA with Mosaic and Citra Hops 6.5% ABV
US$16.00
4-Pack Annexation
West Coast IPA featuring citrus and pine notes with a firm bitterness and semi-dry finish. 7.2% ABV
US$14.00
4-Pack Delta Hurricane
Imperial Milk Stout with Chicory and Coffee. Inspired by the New Orleans traditional coffee and chicory blend, Delta Hurricane is our own take on the coffee milk stout. The base stout recipe is built on flavors of roasted barley, coffee, and dark chocolate balanced by a light punch of American hops on top of a full bodied beer, thanks in part to the addition of lactose. This batch uses the Night Moves Blend from our friends at Passion House Coffee. To round everything out in the New Orleans tradition, we blended in pure chicory sourced from a New Orleans roaster for a subtle woody and nutty character. The resulting beer is part Chicago, part New Orleans, and all Horse Thief Hollow. 8.0% ABV
US$16.00
4-Pack Kitchen Sink
Classic American Pale Ale with a caramel malt backbone featuring a load of hops with Cascade at the forefront. 5.3% ABV
US$12.00
Merchandise - Merchandise
Beanies
US$20.00
Canvas Hat
US$25.00
HTH Koozie
US$3.00
HTH Pint
US$5.00
HTH Sticker
US$3.00
HTH Trailer Hitch
US$10.00
HTH Windbreaker
$
New Hat HTH
US$25.00
HTH Grey Hoodie New
US$60.00
HTH Blue Crewneck Sweatshirt New
US$50.00
Red Long Sleeve Beverly Shirt
US$35.00
Yellow Short Sleeve Beverly Shirt
US$30.00
HTH Short Sleeve Green Shirt
US$30.00
Soul Train Tank Top
US$20.00
Merchandise
Beanies
US$20.00
Canvas Hat
US$25.00
HTH Koozie
US$3.00
HTH Pint
US$5.00
HTH Sticker
US$3.00
HTH Trailer Hitch
US$10.00
HTH Windbreaker
$
New Hat HTH
US$25.00
HTH Grey Hoodie New
US$60.00
HTH Blue Crewneck Sweatshirt New
US$50.00
Red Long Sleeve Beverly Shirt
US$35.00
Yellow Short Sleeve Beverly Shirt
US$30.00
HTH Short Sleeve Green Shirt
US$30.00
Soul Train Tank Top
US$20.00
If you're in the mood for a hearty meal with a cozy vibe, the Horse Thief Hollow Menu is where you need to be. Located at 10426 S Western Ave in Chicago, this spot offers a unique blend of American comfort food with a twist. Whether you're craving something savory like their juicy burgers or looking to try a new take on classic dishes, the menu has something for everyone. With a mix of craft beers and flavorful dishes, it's the perfect place to kick back and enjoy a great meal. Their selection of appetizers, mains, and desserts are made to satisfy any appetite, all served with a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Plus, there's always something new to try, making each visit a fun experience.